What exactly are non-custodial wallets, and how do they differ from custodial wallets?
Helghardt
September 5
Kickstarting our non-custodial wallet series, it’s important to define what a non-custodial wallet is and how it differs from a custodial wallet - let's dive in.
Imagine having a vault that only you hold the key to—this is essentially what a non-custodial wallet offers. Non-custodial wallets are cryptocurrency wallets that give you full control over your private keys, which means you have complete ownership and responsibility for your digital assets. No middlemen, no gatekeepers—just you and your assets.
In contrast, custodial wallets are more like renting a safe deposit box at a bank. The bank (or third party) holds the keys, and while it’s convenient, you’re trusting them with your assets. This means they manage your private keys and, ultimately, control your assets. They can make transactions on your behalf, but they also add a layer of risk since you don’t have direct control.
For anyone thinking about launching a fintech product that involves stablecoins or cryptocurrency, understanding this distinction isn’t just a technical detail—it’s a fundamental business decision. Non-custodial wallets empower users with full control, which can be a major selling point, especially in the era of decentralized finance (DeFi). However, it’s equally crucial that your end users grasp the responsibilities that come with this power. Whether they realize it or not, the decision between custodial and non-custodial wallets affects their risk profile, ease of use, and their financial autonomy.
Top crypto companies emphasize the difference between non-custodial and custodial wallets on their websites, including Coinbase, Binance, Fireblocks, Moonpay, and more.
Custodial vs. Non-Custodial Wallets: A Comparison
Taking it a step further, let's compare custodial and non-custodial wallets side by side.
| Feature | Non-Custodial Wallet | Custodial Wallet |
|---|---|---|
| Ownership of private keys | User fully controls private keys | Third-party (wallet provider) holds private keys |
| Access to funds | Only the user can access and manage funds | The wallet provider can access and manage funds on behalf of the user |
| Security responsibility | User is fully responsible for securing private keys | Security is managed by the wallet provider |
| Control over transactions | User has complete control over transactions | Wallet provider can make transactions on behalf of the user |
| Risk of loss | High if private keys are lost or compromised | Lower for individual mistakes, but there is a risk if the provider is hacked or goes bankrupt |
| Ease of use | Typically more complex, especially for beginners | More user-friendly and convenient |
| Privacy | Greater privacy, no KYC/AML requirements in many cases | Often requires KYC/AML compliance and personal data |
| Recovery options | Limited recovery options; users must safeguard seed phrases | Recovery usually possible via wallet provider |
| Regulatory oversight | Less regulatory oversight, often decentralized | Heavily regulated in many cases, especially in terms of KYC/AML |
| Best for | Advanced users, people who prioritize control and privacy | Users who prefer convenience, lower security responsibility, or don't want to manage keys |
5 non-custodial wallet examples
- MetaMask – One of the most popular non-custodial wallets, MetaMask has over 30 million active users and processes billions of dollars in transactions each month.
- Trust Wallet – Acquired by Binance, Trust Wallet boasts over 60 million users globally, offering support for multiple cryptocurrencies and blockchains.
- Ledger – This hardware wallet has sold over 6 million devices and is trusted for high-security storage of digital assets, primarily used by long-term holders.
- Argent – A smart wallet that focuses on simplifying DeFi interactions, Argent has hundreds of thousands of users and is seeing increasing usage in the DeFi space.
- Zengo – A keyless non-custodial wallet, Zengo is gaining traction with its advanced cryptography, protecting users from seed phrase loss, with over 1 million users.
5 custodial wallet examples
Custodial wallets are typically combined with an exchange component.
- Coinbase – Part of the Coinbase ecosystem, this wallet supports millions of users and processes billions in monthly transaction volume across crypto and fiat currencies.
- Binance – Integrated into Binance, the largest cryptocurrency exchange by volume, this wallet sees massive usage, supporting over 90 million users.
- Crypto.com – Crypto.com’s wallet is used by more than 80 million people and handles billions in transaction volume every month, offering staking, crypto payments, and fiat support.
- Gemini - A secure custodial wallet designed by Gemini, a fully regulated U.S. exchange, with over 13 million users and a strong focus on institutional-grade security and compliance.
- Cash App - A widely-used mobile payment service with over 50 million monthly active users. Cash App offers custodial bitcoin services, allowing users to buy, sell, and hold bitcoin alongside traditional fiat services.
5 interesting things about non-custodial wallets
You can use any supported interface
Non-custodial wallets allow you to choose any supported interface to interact with your assets. For example, you can import your private keys or seed phrases into different platforms like MetaMask, Trust Wallet, or even a hardware wallet like Ledger, giving you flexibility and control over your interface across mobile, desktop, web, and browser plugins.
One private key works on multiple blockchains
A single private key can be used across multiple blockchains that share the same cryptographic standards (e.g., Ethereum and Binance Smart Chain). This allows you to manage assets across different networks without having to create new keys for each blockchain, making multi-chain asset management more streamlined.
Full transaction customization
Non-custodial wallets let you fully customize transactions. You can adjust gas fees for faster or cheaper transactions, replace or cancel transactions before confirmation, and even interact with complex smart contracts, giving you unprecedented control over how and when your transactions are processed.
Below is an example of a signature request to connect OpenSea with a MetaMask wallet.
Offline security options
You can enhance the security of your non-custodial wallet by using hardware wallets like Ledger or Trezor. These devices store your private keys offline, protecting them from online threats like phishing or hacking. With this setup, your private keys never interact with the internet, which greatly reduces the risk of compromise.
No dependence on a centralized entity
Non-custodial wallets operate independently of centralized entities. This means that even if an exchange is hacked, goes bankrupt, or is shut down by regulators, your assets remain secure since you hold the private keys. This decentralization removes single points of failure, making your funds safer from systemic risks.
Interacting with dApps, holding NFTs, and voting in DAOs
Non-custodial wallets are gateways to decentralized applications (dApps), allowing users to directly participate in DeFi, hold and trade NFTs, and vote in decentralized autonomous organizations (DAOs). This makes them essential for anyone looking to be actively involved in the Web3 ecosystem, as they provide seamless interaction without intermediaries, giving users full control over their digital assets and governance rights. Below is an example governance voting outcome for Aave on the snapshot platform.
Conclusion
As you can see, non-custodial wallets open up a whole new way of thinking about security, privacy, control, and how users engage with digital assets. Now that we’ve covered the basics, we’ll continue to dig into the details in upcoming posts.
Follow along on X or LinkedIn, and if you have any questions or areas you'd like us to explore further, feel free to reach out—we’re in this together as we shape the future of finance.
FAQs
How can we help you get started?